Dearie and Cole are two popular (but sort of hated) queen bee boys of Stone Grove High School. But when the famed Mr. Sandman (a serial killer from the seventies) returns to their town-killing a fellow member of Queer Club and brutally hurting another-their whole lives change. And when suspicion falls on Cole, Dearie and Cole will have to do whatever it takes to uncover the real killer, before they and the rest of Queer Club are hunted down. But they're not getting away from the killer without a fight. Along the way, their investigation leads them to face the deeper forces trying to tear their friendship apart, and the dark truth of Dearie's relationship with his ex. Will they find Mr. Sandman?