After Raine Michelson turns down her long-time boyfriend Caleb Anders's marriage proposal, the two are barely co-existing as they enter graduate school at Lindon University. However, that quickly turns upside down following an emotional hookup after devastating news, leading to an unexpected pregnancy. Despite the unanswered questions Caleb has about why Raine broke up with him, he suggests moving in as co-parenting friends and working together at his father's hardware store. When their close proximity feeds into old feelings, the pair must figure out if their love for each other ever ended, and must learn how to face their uncertain future on their own terms, without outside influences—like grief, loss, and fear—getting in the way.