Shirley, Goodness, and Mercy know that an angel's work is never done, especially on New Year's Eve. With an apprentice angel, Will, under their wings, the trio descends upon Times Square, in New York City. When Will spies two strangers in the crowd, he decides that midnight is the perfect time to lend a heavenly helping hand. Lucie Farrara and Aren Fairchild meet after bumping into each other—seemingly by accident—in Times Square on New Year's Eve. They immediately hit it off, but just as quickly, another twist of fate tears them apart. A year later, the two have not forgotten their one serendipitous evening—and neither have Shirley, Goodness, Mercy, and Will. To reunite the young couple, the angels devise a plan to create an unforgettable Christmas miracle.